Do You Understand the Basics of Guardianship? | Best Estate Planning, Wills & Trusts, Medicaid and Probate Lawyer - New York
We help you achieve a peace of mind
and a better future.

Do You Understand the Basics of Guardianship?

Latest News

Special needs children require additional care to address their vulnerabilities, which makes protecting and providing for them particularly challenging. Structuring your estate plan to include the appropriate legal documents in the event of your death is crucial, especially when naming a guardian. Special needs children often require guardianship past the age of 18. However, if your child reaches the age of adulthood (18 years old in most states), as a parent, you need to apply for legal guardianship to make decisions on behalf of your adult child.

What is Guardianship?

A guardianship is the legal process of giving a guardian permission to care for and make decisions for an incapacitated adult. The definition of incapacitation for this purpose is an individual with a clinical diagnosis for a condition keeping them from communicating decisions about their physical care, safety, and health. In legal terms, an incapacitated adult may receive the designation of a protected person or ward. The court is responsible for the approval and appointment of a guardian permitting legal authority and responsibility to care for the individual and their property. The court will oversee the guardian and require an annual report defining the current status of the ward.

Types of Guardianship

There are several types of guardianships, and they may vary by state. A special needs planning attorney can help you identify your state’s guardianship associations, advocacy groups, and other local information important for your loved one’s care. Some of the more common guardianship types in New York include:

  • Guardian of the person – This guardian is responsible for monitoring the care of the special needs person. They are not required to live with them, supervise them daily, or use their own money for care. However, they must ensure the ward receives proper care, supervision, and housing. Guardian decision-making includes most medical care, including end-of-life decisions, vocational planning, and education.
  • Guardian of the property – Special needs individuals who can’t manage their financial affairs but have income from sources other than benefit checks, like other assets and property, require financial oversight to protect their estate. The guardian will handle the financial resources of the ward and file an annual accounting report of their asset status with the court.
  • Limited guardianship – This guardianship applies to only certain decision-making areas such as medical treatment, permitting the ward to make decisions in other areas of their life. This limitation provides the help a special needs individual requires in the least restrictive manner possible. The special needs person under limited guardianship has not been declared medically incompetent.
  • Temporary guardian – This individual is usually court-appointed in an emergency when certain decisions are immediately required. Many states require a permanent guardianship request along with a temporary appointment request. The temporary guardianship usually lasts for up to ninety days. The temporary guardian does not need to be the person requested as the permanent guardian.
  • Successor guardian – The parents of the special needs child should name in their legal documents the next person to be in the role of guardian upon their death or inability to provide care. A special needs lawyer may ask you to consider a co-guardianship with the successor guardian during your lifetime.

Preparing for the Need for Guardianship

Guardianship becomes appropriate when a special needs child reaches 18 years of age and their parents are no longer legal guardians. And exploring the legal options and potential guardians before they reach 18 lets you find the best solution. The following chart generalizes issues involved in self-determination versus guardianship. It is a guideline for understanding when to consider intervention. Usually, high-risk decision categories like requiring extensive medical care or supervision for transferring large sums of money are a good place to focus first.

Type of Decision -e.g., medical or involving a large sum of money Individual’s Ability to Receive, Evaluate and Communicate Relevant Information  Possible Action to Take
High Risk High Capacity Accept the individual’s right to make their own decisions. Explore supported decision-making (SDM).
High Risk Low Capacity Legal intervention indicated – e.g., guardianship of person and/or property
High Risk Moderate Capacity Supported decision-making indicated; talking with the individual to reduce resistance, reduce risk and increase their capacity to understand

Guardianship Alternatives

Are there alternatives to guardianships? Yes, and courts generally favor placing persons in the least restrictive environment. Below are guardianship alternatives from the least to most restrictive.

  • A joint bank account can prevent excessive, unchecked expenditures. Most banks will arrange for benefits checks like Supplemental Security Income (SSI) or Social Security payments to be directly sent to the banking institution for deposit. Funds for repeatable expenses like rent can transfer directly to the landlord, and automatic bill pay can handle utility bills. Certain sums of spending money for the special needs person can be routinely available. The joint bank account owner can oversee the account’s budgeting and money management, remembering to keep the account balance below $2,000 if they receive SSI benefits.
  • A representative payee can receive and manage the funds of a special needs individual via Social Security, Railroad Retirement, or Veterans Benefits Administration. The representative payee receives, manages, and spends these funds to benefit the person with special needs.
  • A durable power of attorney (POA) for property is a document granting legal authority to handle the financial affairs of another. A POA is useful if the special needs person can make basic meaningful decisions and does not require full guardianship but might require support to make complex financial decisions. However, the principal is required to possess a requisite minimum mental capacity to execute the POA. If they do not, Guardianship may be the only alternative to achieve the necessary goals with the least restrictive means.
  • A durable power of attorney for healthcare, in New York called a healthcare proxy, grants decision-making powers to a healthcare agent on behalf of the special needs individual. Decisions like the right to remove a physician from care, the right to medical records, and change a course of treatment are within the scope of a durable POA. Even those patients who currently can make their health care decisions benefit from naming a future representative.
  • An appointment of advocate and authorization identifies an agent to advocate on behalf of the special needs persons with administrative agencies. These agencies can include the state department of cognitive disability, the department of medical assistance, and the department of mental health services. This agent may have specific powers granted to access school or rehabilitation records, the authority to release them, approve placement or services, attend meetings, and generally advocate for the person with a disability. This document must be in writing and witnessed. Some states will require notarization.
  • A HIPAA Release form allows a named individual access to protected medical information about the special needs person. Suppose the patient prefers their parents or other healthcare proxies to discuss their medical information with their doctors, therapists, etc. In that case, this release form must be on file with the attending medical professionals.
  • Trusts can be a less expensive option because there is no bond requirement, it stays out of the court system unless problems arise, and the trust design can protect the beneficiary’s assets without declaring them incompetent by a court. There are many different trust types; each has specific situational benefits that a special needs attorney can help you identify. Your attorney will understand how to set up the appropriate trust that will not render the special needs individual ineligible for SSI, Medicaid, and other important government benefits.
  • Supported decision-making (SDM) allows a designated person or team of trusted supporters to help disabled individuals make decisions about their lives while remaining in charge.

A special needs planning lawyer can help you decide which strategy is best for your adult child, knowing that their needs may change in the future due to either deterioration in health or improvement due to new treatments or drug therapies.

For assistance, please contact our office at 516-518-8586.

Related Articles